Home > Rant > SRS


Spaced repetition system (or SRS) is a way to memorize “items” of knowledge (i.e. vocabulary), by making the student rack his or her brain trying to remember them at increasing intervals. You can find a bit more detailed description about it on Wikipedia. If you tried Anki or the long-term study in zkanji you probably know what I’m talking about. I don’t intend to write about the way SRS works and would avoid any scientific stuff. What follows has probably been said already (I don’t know, I haven’t read what others wrote), but this is a blog, so I just post what I think.

Let me make it clear that I think SRS is a great way to remember things. It has received a lot of criticism (probably, I have only seen a few, but I don’t roam the internet trying to find out what everyone thinks), and some of those partially concur with what I think as well. People who criticize it probably have their reasons to do so, and I’m not going to debunk them, nor am I able to. I just wanted to write about one correct way of using SRS.

This might sound like the opposite of what I wrote so far, but I think SRS is not the best method when you want to learn something new. Although it might be a way to study, but it is rather a way to prevent forgetting what you studied before. If you are like me and don’t use Japanese in your daily life, you ought to forget even some pretty common vocabulary. Preventing this is one purpose of SRS. I have met the opinion that using this method is a waste of time, and that many people learned a language without using spaced repetition. I agree that SRS is not for everyone, and that your experience might tell you to avoid it. There are people who learned a language without every touching textbooks, and textbooks might have slowed them down even. It depends on your environment and skills. If you have the opportunity to communicate a lot in your target language or you are surrounded with that language all the time, the correct way of using SRS might be to not use it at all. It can still be useful, so it is up to every person whether they need it or not. It is also possible that SRS wouldn’t help you because it doesn’t suit your learning style. For example books for learning kanji never helped me, even though a lot of students found them helpful.

I don’t want to tell anyone what they should do, but I have a few ideas regarding the use of spaced repetition systems. I think they are only effective if you combine them with some other study method. For example reading is both great entertainment and an excellent way to study. Even the best writers tend to use the same words and expressions over and over again, so if you read several books from the same author, you can learn without SRS. You could even take reading as a badly tuned SRS, though it doesn’t force you to remember as much as a program used for testing you. Especially if you are lazy and never take the time to learn what you have read. :p Reading Japanese books is “a bit” difficult due to kanji, but fortunately it is not the only way. You could pick any kind of entertainment, collect words you heard or read and study those. It is not a good idea to just add new words to the list (or deck) of an SRS program, because spaced repetition is not effective that way. My opinion is that if you make sure that what you learn with SRS can be associated with something else that you enjoy or use (entertainment, textbooks etc.), and that you try to be exposed to the Japanese language (or any other subject) as much as possible, it is easier to remember things with, than without SRS.

I could write a lot more about the subject, but I’m not confident in my authoritativeness. Just try it before you form an opinion.

As a final word I wanted to tell this to those who complain that the intervals given to words in the zkanji long-term study are too long. Repeating the words with the normal study groups, before adding them to the long-term study list helps a lot. At least if you try to learn brand new vocabulary.

  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: